Carly Smithson - Without You Studio Version

LOLCOPTER Says:

Jul 6, 2008 - i agree too! she looks like amy lee! but amy lee voice is very haunting (in a unqiue sense).

ghfan07 Says:

Jul 8, 2008 - safe.....not my choice of words....there arent many versions better than this. and the live version was great

ghfan07 Says:

Jul 8, 2008 - well i HATE how some people think they know what they are talking about.... but they dont

ghfan07 Says:

Jul 8, 2008 - this and here you come again were def. two of her best performances..... and has anyone else noticed that like almost all of her videos on here are rated five stars?!..... dosent surprise me though, cuz shes totally amazing!

YUPnNOPE Says:

Jul 8, 2008 - i HATE how some people think that some people don't know what they're talking about when they actually do.

Live2Bfre7 Says:

Jul 11, 2008 - NICE.

cbotten106 Says:

Jul 12, 2008 - Carly is something special, both her voice and her spirit!

mikelmn Says:

Jul 16, 2008 - 0:50-0:56 sounds like kelly clarkson

strygywyr02 Says:

Jul 19, 2008 - GOGOGO!!!!

MLluvsJohns92 Says:

Jul 21, 2008 - WOW!!!! This is really really good..her best performance..

elbashamomo Says:

Jul 30, 2008 - she did it very good but not like mariah

DiruKei Says:

Jul 30, 2008 - This song really makes her voice powerful.

loveabitofmilk Says:

Jul 31, 2008 - i know what you mean :D

ghfan07 Says:

Jul 31, 2008 - mikelmn- i kinna see what you're sayin

musikphantom1881 Says:

Jul 31, 2008 - Except maybe Total Eclipse of the Heart God her voice is beautiful....she so should have won

tianabronze Says:

Aug 1, 2008 - I'm not a rock type of person but i love carly she i great

houseofblackleaves Says:

Aug 2, 2008 - You're right. Carly did not sing it like Mariah. She sang it better.

cbotten106 Says:

Aug 8, 2008 - This is simply stunning rendition of this old song. Carly is like a master craftsman with the ultimate set of tools. The voice is just fantastic and she really knows how to use it too.

irishsweethearttx Says:

Aug 9, 2008 - To tell you the truth, I think I liked this better then Mariah's version. I love Mariah's version, but Carly does it better. She should do a permanent rendition, and put it on a CD. Her voice is absolutely beautiful, I love the tone, not to mention her emotion. I think she has so much personality and charisma on stage while she sings, and that will get her to a high place in the future! :)

BlackDragonOfEgypt Says:

Aug 14, 2008 - omg i love her! she reminds me so much of amy lee of evanescence! which is a good thing! :)

BumbleeBeex0 Says:

Aug 14, 2008 - I honestly cannot believe she hasn't been signed yet. I can't believe that the only person besides the obvious two to get a record deal (the David's) is Kristy Lee.. Carly was my favorite girl this season - she is an amazing vocalist and if you haven't seen her on tour - you NEED to. Someone said she reminds them of Amy Lee. Well, she really will after the tour since sings Bring Me To Life by Evanesence. Absolutely stunning; she's beautiful in person too.

mattheo321 Says:

Aug 15, 2008 - haha true ((:

curlingiron7658 Says:

Aug 16, 2008 - Calry is going to get a contract, she said so, she has to wait until after the tour!!!

CatTheCrapOut Says:

Aug 17, 2008 - This is so haunting and emotional. Beautiful.

crazy2hazy Says:

Aug 21, 2008 - carly's version is fantastic, but it's mariah's version that is considered by many one of the greatest vocal performances of all time. I like her tone in higher registers too, but its not better than mariah's