Beethoven Tempest Sonata III movement - 5 pianists play...

MagicSkryabin Says:

Sep 5, 2008 - Beautiful

dadinothebest Says:

Sep 5, 2008 - mmmm la prima per me....

go9zu Says:

Sep 5, 2008 - 1.Very nice,2.I realy don't like it!3....bad piano,good playing (it could be a litle faster),4.veeery sensitive playing,5.Veeery interesting and the "touché" wonderful!! My favorites:1. and 5.

dadinothebest Says:

Sep 5, 2008 - mmm ho cambiato idea!!! il Pianista C è mlt piu espressivo!!;-)

RobertJV24 Says:

Sep 5, 2008 - 4th and 5th being my favourite, 4 a little more so.

xAmandine Says:

Sep 6, 2008 - I agree almost exactly with go9zu. My favourite is A! then E! C is charming and expressive ;), less good in parts but I still prefer it to both B and D. I like D more than B.

kpunkt Says:

Sep 6, 2008 - oh that's dangerous... but anyways... 1 etudelike uninteresting 2 a bit too fast but very beethovenlike "con brio" 3 a bit too slow but very detailed and musical 4 very good tempo, wonderful playing - my favourite 5 beethoven alla Debussy - I don't like it

loxpower Says:

Sep 6, 2008 - Di quelli che hai messo il D... anche se *non* mi sembra di sentire Maurizio Pollini che è il mio interprete preferito della Tempesta... c'è poco "fuoco" in tutte le esecuzioni che hai messo (e non ha a che fare con la velocità!)

vrankov Says:

Sep 7, 2008 - If I was to ask Simon to play it, I would have asked him to play it like #3, but he would not listen to me and would play it like #1. As far as I know Sandro, he will chose to play it like #5. Sandro, please consider #4 and #1 too. Just for the tempo.

enantiodrom Says:

Sep 7, 2008 - Non ho ascoltato la tua versione che vedo occhieggiare nella lista al lato..così, buttandomi potrei dire che il terzo pianista potresti essere tu, il primo mi ricorda Backhaus anche se è meno monocromatico, il terzo corre come Gould ma non ne riconsco il suono, il quinto assomiglia nello stile a Serkin.Comunque Arrau, Nat, Gilels, Schnabel sono tra i miei preferiti. Gieseking è fra i cinque?

pianogirl98 Says:

Sep 8, 2008 - Very interesting to hear the different interpretations of the piece! Each has his/her personality in the music he/she is playing!

mikeluzzo90 Says:

Sep 8, 2008 - Quoto il 4° pianista..la seconda esecuzione è troppo veloce pure per Gold..il terzo è di Sandro Bisotti il resto nn so..bye

nikolaimedtner Says:

Sep 9, 2008 - for me, pianist A please!

musicusblau Says:

Sep 12, 2008 - Hi Sandro, very interesting composition of different interpretations of this piece, which is one of my favourites. 1) This one I prefer to all. It comes the intention of Beethoven the nearest. (Sounds a bit like my interpretation, but I do the arpeggios in another way). 2) I suppose it´s Glenn Gould. This one is very musically played, too, but much too fast. We have an Allegretto here, not "con brio". 3)Too free, Beethoven did not intend this. 4)The articulation is not good. 5)too free

blueyoyi Says:

Sep 23, 2008 - Now here is from a guy who "loves" piano music but is totally ignorant of its specifics and nuances. B - A - C - E - D I believe this is your 2nd survey. Thanks it was fun.

greekyboy123 Says:

Sep 28, 2008 - I like A and D the most - though I lean more toward D as I feel the contrasts are more effectively put across. B I suspect is Gould - shame about the silly tempo, as I feel that with his clarity of texture there could have been a great performance there. C and E not to my liking